Look, LOOK! It's done! My very first Horny Mushroom Pie! Actually, this is my first pie EVER! Oh...this is so exciting...I feel light-headed...woo... Hey, maybe I should show this to Chief Stan. This IS a really special pie and all. I just need a nice Paper Box to put it in. Horny Mushrooms have nice Paper Boxes...do you think you could get one for me?

Reply to “Yes”

I know they're tough to find, but the Horny Mushrooms definitely have them! Beat them up 'till you get one!

Reply to “No”

C'mon, I just need one Paper Box! And not a store-bought one...getting items from monsters shows that you REALLY care.

Turning in the quest

This is perfect! Okay, lemme just...put the pie...in here...carefully...

Additional replies

I know they're tough to find, but the Horny Mushrooms definitely have them! Beat them up 'till you get one!