One of the five seals is indeed broken, and it's totally giving me the heebie-jeebies. I wonder, could we re-seal the Black Mage completely by repairing this seal?

Shoot, I got it now! This seal looks just like the Seal Stone!

If I bring the Seal Stone here, maybe I can fix the seal!

Reply to “Yes”

I'm sure Athena Pierce will give me her seal stone if my theory is true. I've got to get back to Henesys.

Reply to “No”

No, no. That'll never work. Bad, [Name], bad! Why can't you ever think of good ideas?

Turning in the quest

You look alarmed. What did you find at the Temple of Time, [Name]?

(You tell Athena Pierce everything you saw at the temple.)

So my gut was right...